Boy Scouts End Ban on Gay Leaders, Over Protests by Mormon Church
The Boy Scouts of America on Monday ended its ban on openly gay adult leaders.
But the new policy allows
church-sponsored units to choose local unit leaders who share their
precepts, even if that means restricting such positions to heterosexual
men.
Despite this compromise, the Mormon Church said it might leave the organization
anyway. Its stance surprised many and raised questions about whether
other conservative sponsors, including the Roman Catholic Church, might
follow suit.
“The
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is deeply troubled by
today’s vote,” said a statement issued by the church moments after the
Scouts announced the new policy. “When the leadership of the church
resumes its regular schedule of meetings in August, the century-long
association with scouting will need to be examined.”
Only two weeks ago, the Mormon Church hinted that it could remain in the fold so long as its units could pick their own leaders.
The top Boy Scouts
leaders, including Robert M. Gates, the current president and a former
defense secretary who pushed for the new policy, did not immediately
respond to the Mormon declaration. In previous statements, Mr. Gates
expressed the hope that with the exemption for religious groups, the Boy
Scouts might avoid a devastating splintering.
Many scouting leaders said they had not expected the Mormon Church’s sharp response and threat to leave.
“My
assumption was that the concept voted on today had been fully vetted so
as to avoid any unnecessary surprises,” said Jay Lenrow, a longtime
volunteer scout leader in Baltimore who is on the executive committee of
the Scouts’ northeast region and serves on the organization’s national
religious relationships committee.
“I
can only say that I’m hopeful that when the leadership of the L.D.S.
Church meets and discusses the issue, that they will find a way to
continue to support scouting,” Mr. Lenrow added.
Mormons use the Boy Scouts as their main nonreligious activity
for boys, and the Cub Scouts and Boy Scouts units they sponsor
accounted for 17 percent of all youths in scouting in 2013, the last
year for which data have been published.
Under
the policy adopted Monday, discrimination based on sexual orientation
will also be barred in all Boy Scouts offices and for all paid jobs — a
step that could head off looming lawsuits in New York, Colorado and
other states that prohibit such discrimination in employment.
One
legal threat was immediately averted. In response to the change, the
New York State attorney general, Eric T. Schneiderman, announced on
Monday that his office was ending its investigation of the Scouts for
violating state anti-discrimination laws.
The
Boy Scouts’ national executive board, composed of 71 civic, corporate
and church leaders, adopted the changes with 79 percent of those who
participated in a telephone meeting voting in favor, according to an
announcement issued by the Scouts. The announcement did not say how many
board members were not present.
The
policy change, which was expected, was widely seen as a watershed for
an institution that has faced growing turmoil over its stance toward gay
people, even as it struggles to halt a long-term decline in members. It
was praised by gay-rights organizations as a major if incomplete step
toward ending discrimination.
In
2013, facing growing public and internal pressure, the Scouts decided
that openly gay youths could participate, but not adults. That approach
satisfied no one, forcing the ejection of gay Eagle Scouts when they
turned 18 but still causing some conservatives to quit.
Mr. Gates gave an urgent warning in May that because of cascading social and legal changes, the organization had no choice but to end its ban on gay leaders.
In
a statement on July 13, the Mormon Church seemed to suggest that it
could accept the compromise adopted on Monday. The statement said that
any new leadership standard must preserve for its churches “the right to
select Scout leaders who adhere to moral and religious principles that
are consistent with our doctrines and beliefs.”
But
the tone of Monday’s statement from the Mormons, after the formal
announcement of the new Boy Scouts policy, was markedly more negative.
“The
church has always welcomed all boys to its scouting units regardless of
sexual orientation,” the statement by the Mormon Church headquarters
said. “However, the admission of openly gay leaders is inconsistent with
the doctrines of the church and what have traditionally been the values
of the Boy Scouts of America.”
The
statement also suggested another reason the Mormons are considering
withdrawing from the Boy Scouts: the possible creation of its own boys’
organization to serve its worldwide membership.
“As
a global organization with members in 170 countries, the Church has
long been evaluating the limitations that fully one-half of its youth
face where Scouting is not available,” the statement said.
Some
conservative evangelical churches ended ties with the Boy Scouts after
the 2013 decision to admit openly gay youths. Total national enrollment
of youths, which had declined by a few percentage points in many prior
years, fell by 6 percent in 2013 and by 7 percent in 2014, to 2.4
million.
More
departures by religious conservatives are likely, said Russell D.
Moore, president of the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission of the
Southern Baptist Convention. Mr. Moore expressed skepticism about the
Scouts’ promise to let church-sponsored units exclude gay leaders on
religious grounds.
”After
the Scouts’ shift on membership, they told religious groups this
wouldn’t affect leadership,” he said. “Now churches are told that these
changes will not affect faith-based groups. Churches know that this is
the final word only until the next evolution.”
But
scouting executives hope that with Monday’s change they can renew ties
with corporate donors, schools and public agencies and attract parents
who had steered their children away from scouting because of the policy.
“Moving
forward, we will continue to focus on reaching and serving youth,
helping them to grow into good, strong citizens,” said the statement
Monday from the Boy Scouts.
The
toughest challenge, Scout leaders say, may be to capture the time and
enthusiasm of today’s increasingly urban, diverse and over-scheduled
youths. To increase their appeal, the Boy Scouts have built new
adventure camps with mountain biking and zip lines, and have created new
merit badges in fields like robotics and animation.
Correction: July 27, 2015
An earlier version of this article referred incorrectly to the Mormon church’s view of a new Boy Scouts policy on gay adult leaders. The church said it was “deeply troubled” by the policy; there is no evidence that it had privately agreed to the change.
An earlier version of this article referred incorrectly to the Mormon church’s view of a new Boy Scouts policy on gay adult leaders. The church said it was “deeply troubled” by the policy; there is no evidence that it had privately agreed to the change.
No comments:
Post a Comment