The Gay Courier has been established to provide news, information and info on, from and about the gay community, and other social events and happenings from around the world, from all sorts of sources, to all who are interested in this news, information and info!
The postings are as is, and all copyrights and or ownerships are and remain with the original copyright-holder and or owner!
Search This Blog
Monday, July 25, 2016
Think America's terrified of Donald Trump? Check out how the rest of the world's reacting.
After Donald Trump secured the Republican nomination on Tuesday night, the BBC rounded up
the reactions from the global press to Trump's victory. Aside from some gloating
in authoritarian Russia and China, the reaction was pretty shocked.
"The craziest US presidential election campaign begins," Germany's Die Welt
daily wrote. "The unthinkable has come to pass."
You've seen similar coverage from the foreign press throughout Trump's rise,
the tone of which has been a mixture of panic, terror, and gallows humor. France's
Channel 2 once aired a debate titled, "That Donald Trump could become
president of the United States: should we laugh or cry?" In January, the leading
German magazine Der Spiegel published an issue titled,
"Madness: American Agitator Donald Trump." (Der Spiegel)
It's not just Europe. "Trump seems to be a nightmare for everyone here,"
Hanin Ghaddar, managing editor of Now, an English news site based in Lebanon,
said in March. One of
South Korea's largest newspapers, JoongAng
Ilbo, declared itself "dumbfounded" that someone with Trump's views could be
a "leading candidate in the U.S. presidential race." South Africa's City
Press published a piece titled, "God help us all if Trump wins."
Why? Because Trump plays into many countries' worst fears about America.
Part of it is that he embodies the world's worst anti-American stereotypes:
vulgar, violent, cash-obsessed, racist. Trump is everything many people hate
about the United States, so it's no surprise some are infuriated by his
rise.
But it's not just ethos — it's also what he proposes to do to many countries,
particularly American allies. Trump's actual foreign policy vision represents a
fundamental break with decades of American foreign policy. Given that a lot of
American allies depend on those very decades-old policies for their own
security, Trump's rise is more than just cartoonish.
For them, it's legitimately terrifying.
Trump is what many foreigners see as the worst parts of America
One of the most insightful things I've read on foreign views of Trump is by
German political theorist Yascha Mounk, currently teaching at Harvard.
"If a communist propaganda ministry had commissioned a gifted cartoonist to
draw a typically-American rogue, he would have invented a figure like 'The
Donald,'" Mounk writes in the German newspaper Frankfurter
Allgemeine Zeitung. "A man who embodies the wealthy, boorish philistine,
from his self-important attitude to the way his hair is folded this way and
that, and someone for whom nothing is sacred — other than money, bosoms, success
and power."
Germans, Mounk writes, see Trump as "a symptom of a distinctly American
disease":
In no other democracy in the world, it is said, could voters be so openly
motivated by greed, show so little concern for less-privileged fellow citizens
and be so politically ignorant. Only in hate-filled, under-educated 'Ami-land'
could someone like Trump be successful.
Mounk describes Trump as fitting stereotypes of Americans held not just in
Germany but in places around the world. A 2005 Pew
survey of people in 16 nations found that majorities in most countries
described Americans as "greedy" and "violent." A 2005 study in the Journal of
Cross-Cultural Psychology looked at data from 48 non-American
samples, finding that they described the typical American as (among other
things) "arrogant" and "achievement-oriented."
Trump is a man who describes everything he has as "the best," is obsessed
with "winning," and tells his followers that the protesters they beat up had it
coming. He once literally said, "My whole life I’ve been greedy, greedy for
money — but now I want to be greedy for the United States."
Now, most non-Americans don't only see the bad in America — and a lot of the
time, these stereotypes are fodder for jokes rather than taken seriously.
But in Trump, they see the bad parts of America swamping the parts of it they
admire. That's not just in personality, but also the policies he proposes.
Trump's personal qualities would become the ones that define American
governance.
"For [some], Trump's mere existence confirms their worst suspicions of the
United States," Joyce
Karam, the Washington bureau chief for the Arabic daily Al-Hayat,
writes. "In a region already predisposed to anti-Americanism,
Trump’s Islamophobic and racially charged message is reinforcing long-held
suspicions that America is a racist, imperialist nation that wants to exploit
and subjugate the Arab world."
The most famous example, of course, is Trump's proposal to ban Muslim
immigration.
People around the world condemned it because they thought the idea of
discriminating against people based on their religion was reprehensible. It also
tapped into a broader international fear about Trump's candidacy: that by
accepting Trumpism, America itself would become like him.
"For a putative leader of a nation of immigrants to talk in this way is a
watershed moment for the United States," the
Guardian, Britain's left-wing daily, wrote in an editorial. "In Mr Trump’s
America, the famous words associated with the Statue of Liberty would have to be
amended to welcome 'your tired and huddled masses — but no Muslims.'"
But it's also Trump's foreign policies that scare people
(Scott Olson/Getty Images) But for people in many countries, Trump isn't just a problem because of
what he stands for. It's what he actually might do to them once in office that's
scary.
Countries around the world depend on a broadly stable global order, which
itself depends on a superpower that at the very least doesn't behave
erratically.
But Trump has promised everything but stability. His policy proposals include
confiscating
Syrian and Iraqi oil in areas controlled by ISIS, cozying up with Vladimir
Putin, and imposing 45
percent tariffs on Chinese goods that would almost certainly start a trade
war. And his entire case for his foreign policy is often premised on
the idea that he's unpredictable.
Trump has called NATO "obsolete,"
and threatened to destroy the alliance unless America's European allies pay the
United States in return for the troops America stations on the continent.
"Either they pay up, including for past deficiencies, or they have to get out.
And if it breaks up NATO, it breaks up NATO," Trump said at a campaign
rally.
Nice alliance you've got there — shame if anything were to happen to it, he's
telling the world.
He's also suggested that Japan and South Korea should pay for their security
alliances with the United States. But there, he went even further, suggesting
that these countries should maybe just get their own nuclear weapons so the
United States doesn't have to protect them anymore.
These aren't little policy changes. These alliances are literally the
foundation of the post–World War II American strategy, supported (in varying
forms) by every president and both parties.
The basic idea is that American security alliances around the world deter
aggression by hostile powers, like Russia and China, and cement peaceful ties
betweenallies because they're on the same broad side. American alliances
create a web of peace around the world, preventing wars between great powers and
promoting free global commerce. Everybody wins, at least theoretically.
Trump's point of view threatens to torpedo this system. By telling allies
that the US will only support them if they pay up, he's abandoning American
promises to defend them. American allies will come to believe that American
protection hinges on the whims of an unstable and unpredictable leader.
That is terrifying for people in these countries, who have premised their
entire security policies on the existence of American protection. If America
won't protect them, might they then be vulnerable to attack? The alliance
system, which depends on credible American security guarantees, will start to
unravel.
A Trump presidency really would mean a change to America's place in the
world
It's hard to overstate how epochal this is. Trump is, without very much
thought, threatening to change the fundamental security equation for some of
America's closest allies. To take them from protected to vulnerable, with
seemingly no appreciation of the consequences.
"This is basically like, 'Hey, maybe we should think about communism,'"
Jennifer Lind, a professor at Dartmouth who studies East Asia, said of Trump's
comments about Japan and South Korea in
March. "With one blasé comment, this entire foundation of US grand strategy
is just blasted away."
It's no surprise, then, that the reaction to Trump in the foreign press goes
beyond disgust and anger to fear. Trump's foreign policy is all about
unpredictable and radical breaks with the status quo — but the world depends on
America to be the exact opposite of that.
No comments:
Post a Comment